Skip to the content
A Story Department site
The Story Department Est. 2009 · Karel Segers

What just happened??

I have seen The Hurt Locker and I enjoyed it.
But I don’t get the hype.

Is this a memorable movie?
Is it memorable for the right reasons?

I’d love to hear your comments.

I have serious doubts whether most people who voted for the Best Original Screenplay actually did read it. It may be a truly gripping movie, I didn’t think the writing was exceptional.

As to its Best Picture win, by my standards great movies can be watched over and over again. I have serious doubts whether this is such a movie.

Was it ‘important’? In the sense that it is a sign of our times, that it makes a statement about war? Then what was the statement? The quote at the beginning about how war is a drug?

Then the statement has not been heard. Only a very limited audience has seen the movie and it surely won’t make a big difference for America. In that sense, the movie failed.

Again, I have serious doubts whether Oscar will change this.

Very keen to hear your thoughts in the comments.

Karel

Read by

Karel FG Segers

take what's useful, argue with the rest

Entry 228